Introduction

In this article, we will be exploring the world of boiled linseed oil, a popular finishing option for woodworking projects. Boiled linseed oil is known for its rich color, luster, and its ability to enhance the natural beauty of wood. While making boiled linseed oil at home can be dangerous and time-consuming, there are several commercial options available on the market that claim to provide the same benefits. In this article, we will be comparing homemade and store-bought boiled linseed oils, as well as exploring other variations such as polymerized linseed oil and linseed oil with additives.

The Test

To conduct this comparison, the Wood By Wright channel tested several different varieties of boiled linseed oils, including homemade, store-bought, European brands, and other similar products. The goal was to evaluate their color, drying time, application differences, and overall performance as a finishing option.

Homemade vs. Store-Bought Boiled Linseed Oil

The color and drying time of both homemade and store-bought boiled linseed oil were found to be very similar. While homemade boiled linseed oil may take slightly longer to dry, the difference is minimal. Both options provide the desired texture and luster that boiled linseed oil is known for.

Other Brands and Varieties

  1. Farger Maker: This brand was found to be very similar in smell, application, and fluidity to homemade boiled linseed oil. Although specific information about the absence of dryers was not readily available, the overall consensus is that it is a high-quality product.

  2. Albach: This brand, which is cold-pressed and boiled, offers a lighter color and better mixing properties with other colors. It does not contain chemical dryers, making it a popular choice among painters.

  3. Plaza: Available on Amazon, Plaza offers a double-boiled linseed oil that is thicker in consistency. It may not penetrate as well as other varieties but is readily available in various sizes.

  4. Tried and True: This American company offers a range of boiled linseed oil options. Their Danish oil is a straight polymerized linseed oil with no dryers or VOCs, making it food-safe and highly rated. They also offer boiled linseed oil with beeswax and boiled linseed oil with natural resin for added benefits.

  5. SafeCoat: While not specifically boiled linseed oil, these products offer various natural ingredients and low VOCs. The clear penetrating oil provides good penetration, while the oil and wax finish offers more sheen and increased penetration.

Conclusion

Based on the test results, the Wood By Wright channel made several conclusions about the different boiled linseed oil options. In Canada, Ombak was deemed a cost-effective choice, while Farger Maker was recommended for European buyers. Plaza, while readily available, didn’t penetrate as well as other options. Tried and True’s range of products, including their Danish oil, received high praise for their quality and safety. SafeCoat’s offerings were also deemed safe and effective, with the clear penetrating oil being a close match to traditional boiled linseed oil.

In conclusion, boiled linseed oil remains a popular choice for woodworkers due to its ability to enhance and protect wood while providing a beautiful finish. Whether you choose to make your own or opt for a store-bought product, there are a variety of options available to suit different preferences and applications. Make sure to consider factors such as drying time, color consistency, and safety when selecting the right boiled linseed oil for your woodworking projects.