Introduction
In this article, we will be conducting a comparison and review of three impact tools: Dewalt, Porter Cable, and Porter Cable Brushless. These tools are all 20 volts and have been used extensively over the years. We will be examining their performance and evaluating how they stack up against each other. Keep in mind that this review is based on real-world experiences and not on scientific testing.
Key Points
Dewalt: The Dewalt impact tool has been in use for approximately six years and has proven to be reliable. The battery charges quickly, and despite its age, it still performs well.
Porter Cable: The Porter Cable impact tool is around five years old and came with a newer battery that was purchased separately. This tool has also been used extensively and has had its casing replaced after it broke due to a fall. The replacement casing was affordable and easily available online.
Porter Cable Brushless: The Porter Cable Brushless impact tool is a newer model known for its high torque power. This tool was tested using the old battery from the older Porter Cable model, which is approximately five to six years old.
Performance Test
To evaluate the performance of these impact tools, a three and a half-inch deck screw was used. Each tool was used to drive the screw into a wooden surface, and their performance was compared.
Dewalt: The Dewalt impact tool effortlessly drove the screw into the wood, showcasing its power and efficiency.
Porter Cable: The older Porter Cable model, despite its age and casing replacement, performed exceptionally well, even surpassing the Dewalt in speed.
Porter Cable Brushless: The newer Porter Cable Brushless model, using the old battery from the older model, also performed impressively. Though slightly slower than the previous two models, it still effectively completed the task.
Comparison and Analysis
After conducting the performance test, it is clear that all three impact tools are capable of getting the job done efficiently. However, there are noticeable differences between them.
Size and Weight: The Dewalt impact tool is larger in size compared to the Porter Cable models. Additionally, the Dewalt is lighter in weight than both the Porter Cable and Porter Cable Brushless models.
Speed: The Porter Cable impact tool, despite being older, demonstrated faster performance than the Dewalt. The Porter Cable Brushless model, while slightly slower than the previous two, was still able to drive the screw effectively.
Torque: The Porter Cable Brushless model boasts the highest torque power among the three. This makes it suitable for more demanding tasks that require additional strength.
Battery Performance: All three tools have batteries that have held up well over time. The reviewer did not encounter any problems with the battery life or performance.
Conclusion
In conclusion, based on real-world experience and performance testing, the Dewalt, Porter Cable, and Porter Cable Brushless impact tools are all reliable options for various tasks. The Dewalt showcases efficient power and a lightweight design, while the Porter Cable models excel in speed and reliability. The Porter Cable Brushless model stands out with its high torque power, making it an excellent choice for heavy-duty applications. Ultimately, the choice between these tools depends on individual preferences and the specific requirements of the task at hand.
